Arby’s has long been celebrated for its “We Have The Meats®” slogan and its signature roast beef sandwich. Yet behind the scenes lies a world of off-menu creations—secret items that loyal fans have been ordering for years. In this ultimate guide, we’ll reveal the best-kept secrets of Arby’s secret menu, provide details on ingredients and prices, and share insider tips on how to order these hidden treasures. Whether you’re a fast-food aficionado or a curious first-timer, read on to discover how you can elevate your Arby’s experience with secret menu hacks!
What Is the Arby’s Secret Menu?
Before diving into the list of secret items, it’s important to understand what exactly a “secret menu” is. In the context of Arby’s, the secret menu isn’t an official list displayed in the restaurant. Instead, it’s a collection of custom orders and modifications that have become popular among customers. These items often combine multiple ingredients from the regular menu in innovative ways, giving you an experience that’s both familiar and refreshingly different.
Key Points About the Secret Menu:
- Unofficial but Well-Known: Most Arby’s employees are familiar with many secret orders—even if they aren’t listed officially.
- Customization Rules: You can often ask for extra sauces, swap breads (a concept known as “The Bread Switch”), or pile on extra meat.
- Varied by Location: Not every Arby’s location may offer every secret item, so it’s a good idea to ask before ordering.
- Pricing: Secret menu items typically fall in the $4.99 to $12 range, with some hearty options like the Meat Mountain costing closer to $10 or more.
Arby’s Secret Menu Items
In this section, we break down the most popular secret menu items, how they’re made, and what you can expect to pay.
1. Arby’s Meat Mountain
What It Is:
The Meat Mountain is the undisputed king of Arby’s secret menu. Designed for the true carnivore, it’s a colossal sandwich that combines nearly every type of meat available at Arby’s—often including chicken tenders, roast turkey, ham, brisket, corned beef, Angus steak, and crispy bacon. Many versions also include layers of melted Swiss and cheddar cheeses, all stacked between soft sandwich buns.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Crispy chicken tenders
- Sliced roast turkey
- Pit-smoked ham
- Slow-smoked brisket
- Roast beef
- Angus steak
- Crispy bacon
- Swiss & cheddar cheese (melted on top)
Price & Nutrition:
Typically priced around $10 to $13 depending on location and any extra additions (such as adding a fish filet for a “Denali-style” twist). It’s a caloric behemoth—with estimates ranging from 800 to over 1,000 calories—so prepare for an indulgent feast!
2. Arby’s Melt
What It Is:
Once a staple on the regular menu, the Arby’s Melt has now joined the secret ranks. This sandwich features thinly sliced roast beef smothered in a rich, gooey cheddar cheese sauce, all served on a toasted sesame seed bun. It’s a simple yet satisfying upgrade to the classic roast beef.
Ingredients & Composition:
- 2 ounces of thinly sliced roast beef
- Warm cheddar cheese sauce
- Toasted sesame seed bun
Price & Nutrition:
Prices vary by location, but you can expect it to be in the $4.50 to $6 range. With moderate calories (around 330 per serving), it’s a slightly lighter option than the Meat Mountain.
3. Bacon Beef ‘n Cheddar
What It Is:
Take the beloved Beef ‘n Cheddar sandwich and add an extra twist: bacon. This modification upgrades the classic combination of thin-sliced roast beef and cheddar cheese sauce by incorporating crispy bacon. It’s a savory delight for anyone who can’t get enough of bacon’s irresistible crunch.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Thin-sliced roast beef
- Cheddar cheese sauce
- Extra crispy bacon
- Served on an onion roll
Price & Nutrition:
This item generally costs around $5 to $8, depending on the location and any extra modifications. Nutritional values will vary (around 520 cal), but expect a hearty dose of protein with an extra fat boost from the bacon.
4. Double Stacked Reuben
What It Is:
For those craving something extra meaty, the Double Stacked Reuben is an excellent choice. This off-menu item doubles the amount of meat in the classic Reuben sandwich, giving you 7 ounces of corned beef instead of the usual 3.5 ounces. Combined with sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and extra dressings on toasted rye bread, it’s a hearty meal that won’t leave you wanting.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Double the corned beef (7 oz total)
- Sauerkraut
- Melted Swiss cheese
- Toasted rye bread
- Extra dressing (often Thousand Island)
Price & Nutrition:
Typically priced at around $6.50 to $7.50, this sandwich is a protein powerhouse with higher calorie counts reflective of its generous meat portions.
5. French Dip Max
What It Is:
The French Dip Max is a bold upgrade to the standard French Dip & Swiss sandwich. It comes with double the amount of thinly sliced roast beef (7 oz) and is served on a sub roll with a side of warm au jus for dipping. Adding Swiss cheese takes the flavor to another level, making it a favorite for those looking for a heartier option.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Thinly sliced roast beef (7 oz)
- Swiss cheese
- Toasted sub roll
- Warm au jus for dipping
Price & Nutrition:
Expect a price of approximately $6 to $8. This sandwich is more filling than its regular counterpart and offers an extra punch of flavor and protein.
6. Roast Beef ‘n Swiss Sandwich
What It Is:
This sandwich transforms the classic roast beef into a deli-style delight. Featuring 3.5 ounces of roast beef layered with big-eye Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, and spicy brown mustard—all on honey wheat bread—the Roast Beef ‘n Swiss is a testament to Arby’s commitment to quality ingredients.
Ingredients & Composition:
- 3.5 oz roast beef
- Big-eye Swiss cheese
- Lettuce, tomato, and onion
- Mayo and spicy brown mustard
- Honey wheat bread
Price & Nutrition:
Usually available for around $4.50 to $6.00, this sandwich provides a well-balanced meal with both taste and nutrition in mind.
7. Ham ‘n Swiss Sandwich
What It Is:
For those who enjoy a milder meat flavor, the Ham ‘n Swiss Sandwich is a delightful alternative. This secret menu item combines thinly sliced, oven-roasted ham with melted Swiss cheese, fresh tomato slices, lettuce, onion, and a spread of mayonnaise and spicy brown mustard on honey wheat bread.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Oven-roasted ham
- Melted Swiss cheese
- Tomato, lettuce, and onion
- Mayo and spicy brown mustard
- Honey wheat bread
Price & Nutrition:
Typically found in the $4.00 to $5.50 range, it’s a great option for those looking for a lighter yet flavorful sandwich.
8. Super Roast Beef Sandwich
What It Is:
A hearty take on the classic roast beef, the Super Roast Beef Sandwich comes with extra meat, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and Arby’s signature red ranch sauce. Some variations include an extra slice of cheddar cheese for that added melty goodness.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Extra slices of roast beef
- Fresh lettuce and tomato
- Red ranch sauce
- Sesame seed bun
- Optional cheddar cheese
Price & Nutrition:
Prices generally hover around $4.50 to $6.00, making it a robust yet affordable option for those who crave an extra-meaty sandwich.
9. Ultimate BLT
What It Is:
Bacon lovers rejoice—the Ultimate BLT is a secret menu item that takes the classic BLT to new heights. With extra crispy bacon (sometimes up to eight strips), fresh lettuce, tomato, and creamy mayonnaise on toasted honey wheat bread, this sandwich is a must-try for anyone who adores bacon.
Ingredients & Composition:
- Up to eight strips of crispy bacon
- Fresh lettuce and tomato
- Creamy mayonnaise
- Toasted honey wheat bread (or marbled rye, upon request)
Price & Nutrition:
Generally available for around $5.50 to $7.00, it offers a robust flavor experience that emphasizes bacon without breaking the bank.
10. Turkey ‘N Cheddar and Other Turkey Variations
What They Are:
For those who might be looking for an alternative to beef, Arby’s secret menu also offers turkey-based options. The Turkey ‘N’ Cheddar, for instance, replaces roast beef with freshly sliced turkey on an onion roll. This sandwich is then dressed with red ranch sauce and melted cheddar cheese. Other variants include the Turkey Classic Sandwich and Turkey Reuben, each offering a unique twist on turkey.
Ingredients & Composition (Turkey ‘N’ Cheddar):
- Freshly sliced turkey
- Melted cheddar cheese
- Red ranch sauce
- Toasted onion roll
- Option to add bacon for an extra cost
Price & Nutrition:
Typically, turkey options are priced similarly to their roast beef counterparts, often ranging between $4.50 and $6.50.
Bonus: Secret Sauces and Custom Modifications
A hidden world within Arby’s secret menu is the realm of sauces and add-ons. Many customers swear that a custom sauce combination can make an already delicious sandwich unforgettable. Here are some popular choices:
DIY Combinations:
Some enthusiasts like to create their own combinations by mixing ingredients from two different secret menu items. For instance, ordering a Turkey ‘N’ Cheddar and asking for extra bacon and a switch to marbled rye bread creates a fusion that’s uniquely yours.
Custom Sauce Pairings:
Try blending Arby’s signature sauce with a dash of Spicy Horsey Sauce or a swirl of Buffalo Sauce mixed with Ranch. These combinations can elevate your sandwich without costing much extra—usually around an extra $0.25 per modification.
Extra Toppings:
Beyond the standard veggies, many fans ask for additional onion tanglers or crispy fried onions to add crunch. Adding cheese or extra bacon can also be done without a fuss if you specify your order clearly.
Tips for the Ultimate Arby’s Experience
To wrap up our guide, here are some additional tips to help you make the most of your Arby’s secret menu adventure:
Plan Your Visit:
Try ordering during off-peak hours when the staff may be less busy and more willing to accommodate custom orders.
Ask for Recommendations:
Don’t hesitate to ask the server or manager for their personal favorite secret menu hack—they might suggest a modification you never thought of!
Experiment with Sauces:
A simple extra sauce can transform a standard sandwich into something extraordinary. Consider asking for a custom blend.
Share Your Experience:
Capture your secret menu creation on social media and tag Arby’s or use popular hashtags. You’ll join a community of fans who share tips and experiences.
Stay Updated:
The secret menu is ever-changing. Follow food blogs, social media pages, or even Arby’s local branch announcements to stay in the loop about new secret items or price adjustments.
Know Your Limits:
Some secret menu items, like the Meat Mountain, are incredibly filling. Consider sharing with a friend or saving part of your order for later.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Are all secret menu items available at every Arby’s location?
Not necessarily. Availability can vary by region and by the familiarity of the staff with secret menu orders. It’s always a good idea to ask or call ahead if you’re looking for a particular item.
Will ordering a secret menu item cost more?
Prices for secret menu items generally align with or slightly exceed those of regular menu items. For example, while a classic roast beef sandwich might cost around $4.50, a heavily modified option like the Meat Mountain can cost upwards of $10.
Can I modify a secret menu item further?
Absolutely. One of the best aspects of Arby’s secret menu is its flexibility. You can request additional toppings, switch up the bread, or mix sauces to your liking.
How do I know if the staff understands my secret menu order?
Be clear and confident in your order. If the server seems unsure, politely explain the components of your secret item. Most employees are familiar with popular requests like the Meat Mountain or French Dip Max.
Conclusion
Arby’s secret menu is a dynamic playground for food enthusiasts who love to explore beyond the standard fare. With offerings ranging from the towering Meat Mountain to the delicately balanced Roast Beef ‘n Swiss, there’s something for every taste and every appetite. Not only do these secret menu items provide a fresh twist on classic favorites, but they also offer incredible value for money and a chance to create a meal that’s uniquely yours. Whether you’re in the mood for a meaty indulgence, a cheesy delight, or a lighter yet flavorful option, Arby’s secret menu promises an exciting culinary journey that’s waiting to be discovered.